Klute
Klute (1971)
Starring: Donald Sutherland
, Jane Fonda
, Roy Scheider
, Charles Cioffi
Directed by: Alan J. Pakula
There are many movies from 1970s I have not seen, and I constantly have to remind myself that I’m looking at them through Modern Day Glasses. There are certain expectations I have that are just not going to happen because the films that formed those expectations had not been made yet in 1974. All of the twist endings I have been absorbing over the last decade were not the trend at the time the Klute script was written. So I have to check myself.
The setup: When Tom Gruneman disappears, John Klute (Sutherland), is hired by his Tom’s friend and co-worker Peter Cable (Cioffi) to carry on the investigation once the police have given up. Klute’s only trail is a call girl, Bree Daniels (Fonda), whose name appears in letters addressed to her by Gruneman.
Klute’s a quiet guy, but Sutherland can emote more with just a look than most actors can with a full script page of dialogue. I love putting Klute in the position of taking over the investigation from “the professionals” who can only offer up abandonment as the reason of Gruneman’s disappearance. Klute goes forward, studying his only lead with quiet strategy, renting a room in her building and tapping her phone.
Jane Fonda won the Academy Award for this performance as Bree Daniels. This was probably due to the two or three scenes with her psychiatrist (ugh), where Bree lays down the Hooker’s Manifesto. To me, it seemed over the top. Her character is a mid-class hooker who tries to land modeling and acting gigs during the day. Maybe she’s playing the character of a melodramatic person, someone who tries to give an award-winning speech even if they’re just ordering a cup of coffee. If not, she’s really hamming it up. I’ve never really picked this up in any of her other performances, save maybe On Golden Pond
, but now I’ll have to go back and look. Any chance to watch Barbarella
again.
What she did pull off were the quiet moments, moments that many audiences wouldn’t stand for today. The character arrives home. The character eats. The character reads. The character listens to the radio. Quiet scenes of the mundane that take up valuable minutes of screen time, and I love them. Filmmakers should really take the time when possible to let their characters just live.
Other great things: Roy Scheider as Bree’s former pimp. The brief dialogue he shared with Klute had me smiling. Scheider was such a great actor. I also enjoyed much of the score in the film. It is very haunting and worked well near the beginning of the movie when we had so few clues and the mystery lay before us.
And then, the thriller is gone. The premise of the Gruneman’s disappearance and the journey through that mystery is — to me, at least — what should have fueled this film.
But it’s not. The movie seems to be about the power of the woman over the powerful man, and how that man reacts once his weaknesses are exposed. That’s a good theme. But I think the opportunity for a really good detective story was missed here. The answer to the plot’s question, or at least the “Who” portion of it, is given far too early in the film.
Which left me scratching my head. That couldn’t be it. They’re going to switch it up. They can’t be giving me the answer already.
They were giving me the answer already. Still, this is a good, well-paced film with an Oscar win attached, and it has some great performances by some classic actors. It is well worth checking out.
Just don’t expect the twist ending.